Commercial and Industrial Loans - still falling
Consumer Loans - - - - - - - - - still falling
Real Estate Loans - - - - - - - - still falling
At this stage in the business cycle, we expect to see real estate loans turn positive first.
Commercial and Industrial Loans will turn positive in the next 6 months, along with Consumer Loans.
Here is the data.
Click on each graph for a larger view.
First, Commercial and Industrial Loans

Commercial and Industrial Loans in percent.

Next, Real Estate Loans
Real Estate Loans - in percent
Consumer Loans

Consumer Loans - in percent